Automation comes to LIES PEOPLE TELL!

Use the form to jump into the fray!
(This page is still under construction -- send mail
to spinner@2xtreme.net to report problems.)


Lies People Tell
survey

Should the liar tell his parents the truth?


The Lie That Sent My Own Brother 1000 Miles Away
please don't use my name

When I was 12 me and my friend were at my house and no one was home.   I knew that my older brother had been smoking pot, so I figured  that he would have some in his room.  Me and my friends were curious about the taste and what it felt like to smoke pot and be high. so we searched my brother's room, and we found some. We smoked it up.  We only took a few hits. I became high as a kite!

The whole house smelled like it because we were stupid and we didn't do it outside and my parents came home and smelled it.  They asked me what happened and I said,  "I don't know.  It smelled like this when I got home."  So they blamed it on my brother and sent him away to boarding school 1,000 miles away.   I still  haven't gotten the nerve to tell them the truth.  I feel bad but I can't tell them.  I'm afraid they will send me away to boarding school like him.

Should the liar tell his parents the truth?

YES


You know your brother already knows the truth.  It can only make matters worse the longer you hold off telling the truth.  Your brother is going to be your brother for the rest of your life and you owe it to him and yourself to keep your
relationship as loving as possible.

If you preface your talk with your parents by saying, "Listen I have been terrified that you are going to send me away to boarding school if I tell you this, so please don't send me away, I love you and I love my brother and I have to be honest so here goes..."  Something like that will show that you care.  I'm sure you had no idea that lying about the smell was going to get
your brother shipped away, so don't feel guilty but just try to clean up things as much as you can as soon as you can. -- Chris

By all means, suck it up and tell the truth! I understand lying to protect yourself, but your lie has cost SOMEONE ELSE their freedom. This is evil. Rectify this at once, and take your lumps like a man. -- Vic



Tell your parents that you and your friends were snooping, as twelve-year-olds will, and you are so sorry, you would never ever try that again.  Be a brother! From someone with four older brothers, much older than you, I know you will never forgive yourself if you don't stand up for him. No one else is. If you can't count on your family... better late than never. If you don't, and have any shred of conscience: you'll never forgive yourself.  He deserves to be home with his family and friends. -- Su Anna


That's f***ed up!  He should tell the truth because his brother got punished for nothing! Even I thinks that's not right! -- Lloyd


No matter what you do, your brother is still your brother, and until you or he has left this earth, you'll be connected to him like a branch to a tree.  The guilt may forever be there, but it will lessen considerably should you ever have the conscience to think about your brother's loss of freedom and family and confess your wrong-doing.  Your parents should also realize that you were only twelve at the time, and that kids around that age tend to experiment to have experience.   The difference is, not most kids would directly or indirectly send their own brother 1, 000 miles from home. -- Janie


You should tell your parents, even though you'll probably get in trouble, it's not worth it.( having your brother so many miles any and he doesn't know why, even! ) -- Anon


You should tell them the truth.  I'm sure your brother has a clue what happened and he's probably pretty pissed off.  If you don't tell, you'll never be able to live with yourself.  10 years from now when you decide it's safe to come out with it will be too late and your relationship with your brother will be ruined if it's not already.  It's not worth it.  When you do something wrong you deserve the consequences, no matter what they are.  Go for it! -- A.S. Taylor


THIS IS A VERY DIFFICULT SITUATION; INDEED, YOU MAY GET SENT AWAY ALSO. I THINK IT WOULD BE BEST IF YOU WAITED UNTIL YOUR BROTHER CAME BACK AND THE TWO OF YOU ARE A LOT OLDER ( I MEAN WITH GRAND CHILDREN).  YOU MAY THEN WANT TO TELL THE TRUTH.  THEN AGAIN, YOUR BROTHER MAY RESENT YOU FOR THE REST OF HIS LIFE, SO MAYBE THAT'S NOT SUCH A GOOD IDEA TO TELL AT ALL. --  LNBROWN19


Doesn't anybody seem to care about the brother? It's all "you should cultivate your relationsghip with him for your own sake," or "You should tell the truth to rid yourself of guilt" but when it comes down to it A) It was the brother's pot to begin with, and B) He's the one in boarding school.   The little brother oughtta ask his brother what he should do! If his brother is sensible, he'll say "forget it" since his parents are unlikely to recall him. (Then again I doubt I'd want to come home to parents who'd send me away for something my brother told them without listening to me.  It was just some pot, for crying out loud!) If the brother is merciless, he can say, "bite the bullet" and his misfortune (again, if you could call it that) would be rectified. Simple as that. -- Mark Henshaw

 

 

 


NO


Unless this is a burden you feel you are having to carry on your soul. Telling the truth might set your soul free, but it could create a rift in your day-to-day life that might be a real pain in the ass. -- Chuck

He should definitely NOT tell his parents the truth. what he should do is say some guys had come to talk to his bro. and they sparked up in the house. if his parents ask why he didn't tell the truth the first time then he should tell them that he was trying to cover for his bro. but it backfired on him. -- David


Telling the truth is important when you feel guilty but not when you are afraid.  He shouldn't tell them because he doesn't know what will happen. -- Moe


I think he shouldn't tell because the brother had the pot anyway and he wasn't supposed to, right?  I mean, it's not like he/she got the pot, brought it to the house, smoked it, and then blamed it on the brother.  It was already in the brother's possession. -- Cassia



 

Back to LiesPeopleTell Main Page